We made Spooooooky Eyes votives a few years ago. Since
ours are already made, I thought I'd try an "almost-tutorial."
Cut (left) or tear (right) rectangles from black paper.
Punch two "eyes" in each.
Using Mod Podge and a large paintbrush, stick all of your
rectangles onto your votive.
Be careful not to cover the punched holes while overlapping the pieces.
(We put an extra coat of Mod Podge on top, too.)
Allow to dry.
Use a Sharpie to dot a pupil in each eye.